Join us at Ali’s Upper Crust, the top-rated pizza destination in New Castle, PA. Enjoy our signature pizzas, delicious sandwiches, and homemade soups, all made with fresh ingredients. Savor quality flavors and exceptional service at 1700 Highland Ave. Giv
Service: Kerbside pickup / Delivery / Takeaway / Dine-in
Ali’s Upper Crust, located on 1700 Highland Ave in New Castle, PA, sets a high bar for pizza lovers seeking authentic, flavorful pies with a hometown vibe. This locally cherished pizza restaurant combines a welcoming atmosphere with expertly crafted dishes that speak to both casual diners and dedicated food enthusiasts.
Their signature Pepperoni Pizza stands out with its thinly sliced pepperoni, allowing each piece to crisp perfectly while releasing a rich, savory flavor. The crust, a yeast-raised dough with a pleasing chew, offers the ideal balance—crisp on the edges and tender within—echoing the quality found in well-loved pizzerias of nearby regions. The cheese blends buttery richness without overwhelming, beautifully browned to complement the sauce’s subtle tanginess, which strikes just the right note without being too sweet or acidic.
The Philly Cheese Steak Hoagie here is exceptional, transforming a classic sandwich into an elevated experience. Baked in a pizza oven, the crusty roll envelops juicy beef, melted provolone, cheddar, grilled onions, and pepper rings. Its generous filling leaves a lasting impression. This dish not only satisfies but invites repeat enjoyment, with loyal customers praising its hearty portions and well-balanced flavors. It's an ideal choice for those craving a substantial, comforting meal beyond traditional pizza.
Ambiance at Ali’s Upper Crust adds to the appeal. The space is straightforward and unpretentious, reminiscent of the classic pizza shops that have long served as neighborhood gathering spots. Friendly staff enhance the experience, attentive to customer preferences and ensuring orders come out exactly right—whether that’s a particular crust crispness or cheese browning. The vibe is casual, making it a great spot for families, friends, and local regulars who appreciate good food served with genuine warmth.
Beyond pizza and hoagies, the menu offers sides like garlic knots bursting with garlicky flavor, hearty pastas such as rigatoni and spaghetti, and refreshing salads including Italian Chef’s and garden varieties. This variety caters well to a broad audience, accommodating varying appetites and tastes while maintaining consistent quality.
In all, Ali’s Upper Crust has earned a reputation as New Castle’s go-to for authentic, satisfying pizza and more. The dedication to crust texture, generous toppings, and customer service sets it apart. It’s a culinary gem for those in the area looking for a flavorful, no-frills dining experience that feels both familiar and special.
