Menu of Ali’s Upper Crust in New Castle, Pennsylvania, USA

Menu Overview

Ali’s Upper Crust in New Castle, PA, stands out as a beacon for pizza lovers seeking authentic, feel-good flavors wrapped in a warm, neighborhood atmosphere. Nestled at 1700 Highland Ave, this pizza joint serves up more than just pie—it offers an experience rooted in quality ingredients, generous portions, and genuine hospitality.

The crown jewel of Ali’s Upper Crust is undoubtedly their Pepperoni Pizza. The thinly sliced pepperoni blankets the pizza evenly, allowing each slice to crisp and release its full, spicy flavor. The crust strikes a perfect balance—airy yet chewy, a testament to a yeast-raised dough that’s thoughtfully crafted and baked to golden perfection. The buttery cheese used here isn’t mere coverage; it’s a decadent layer that melts beautifully and browns just right, complementing the perfectly balanced tomato sauce that is neither too tangy nor too sweet.

For those seeking heartier fare, the Philly Cheese Steak Hoagie is a revelation. As described by local enthusiasts, it boasts a pizza oven-baked crusty roll filled with juicy, ample portions of beef steak, provolone, cheddar, grilled onions, and pepper rings. This sandwich transcends the usual offering with its generous filling and a crust that adds a satisfying texture. It's substantial enough that half a sandwich leaves you full, and intriguingly, the reheated leftovers reportedly taste even better, echoing the careful thought invested into every menu item.

Beyond pizza and sandwiches, Ali’s Upper Crust presents mouthwatering options like the Stromboli and Personal Pizzas with unique toppings such as banana peppers, adding variety and spice to the menu. Their soups and salads—ranging from a comforting homemade wedding soup to crisp garden salads and an Italian chef's salad—provide balanced options for lighter palates or complementary sides. The beloved Garlic Knots, priced reasonably at $7.99, round out the meal with a garlicky punch that accentuates the Italian roots of the cuisine.

What truly elevates the Ali’s Upper Crust experience is the customer-focused service. Staff are attentive, ensuring orders are just right—whether it’s browning the cheese to your preference or welcoming you with a smile. The humble, slightly old-school storefront exudes a clean, unpretentious charm that invites diners to relax and savor their food amidst a friendly environment where good music often plays and community vibes resonate.

Highly praised by regulars, Ali’s Upper Crust holds its own against pizza heavyweights in nearby regions, delivering a taste that satisfies both traditional and adventurous palates alike. Whether you’re craving a spicy buffalo pie, a classic Sicilian slice, or a hefty steak hoagie, this menu confidently covers all bases.

In summary, Ali’s Upper Crust offers more than just excellent pizza; it brings together craftsmanship, hearty flavors, and heartfelt service. This makes it a treasured destination for anyone in New Castle hunting for pizza perfection or a savory sandwich that feels like home.